Captains
| 2003 (8-3) | 2004 (11-3) | 2005 (10-2) |
| Justin Bell | Brock Harner | Evan Arndt |
| Shawn Dougherty | Greg Shoemaker | Evan Bair |
| Jonathan Hower | Brett Stoops | Billy Ortman |
| Clayton Wood | Nate Rolon |
| 2006 (5-6) | 2007 (6-5) | 2008 (7-3) |
| Adam DeGroft | Corey Beaver | Dan Buckley |
| Nate Murren | Tyler Zittle | Tyler Fodor |
| Luke Reichart | | Luke Redding |
| Brian Zelanko | | Jerrod Reynolds |
| 2009 (9-3) | 2010 (10-1) | 2011 (7-4) |
| Tyler Fodor | Kyle Arentz | Mitchell Crouse |
| Jesse Heiser | Sean Doherty | Dan Crowe |
| Brent Shultz | Luke Frymyer | Jonathan Justice |
| Corbin Wood | Tanner Mitz | Ryan Vaughn |
| Austin Reynolds | Dustin Crouse |
| | Ryan Griffin |
| 2012 (7-4) | 2013 (12-1) | 2014 (3-7) |
| Dustin Crouse | Darren Dickensheets | Dustin Duvall |
| Larry Griffin | Dustin DeGroft | Devyn Houck |
| Ryan Griffin | Garrett Trout | Lucas Reynolds |
| Cody Hartlaub | Trevor Hildebrand | Ryan Dickensheets |
| L.J. Miles | |
| 2015 (2-8) | 2016 (8-3) | 2017 (9-2) |
| Cody Boyd | Malachi Fodor | Corbin Brown |
| Ryan Dickensheets | Tanner Noble | Malachi Fodor |
| Daniel Dudenhoeffer | Ben Snouffer | Jakob Lane |
| Jesse Lemmon | Wes Storey | Dylan Morey |
| Colin McNeal | | |
| 2018 (7-4 ) | | |
| Corbin Brown | | |
| Malachi Fodor | | |
| Jakob Lane | | |
| Dylan Morey | | |
